When You Don't Feel Bonded to Your Baby Right Away

They put the baby on your chest and you waited for the feeling, the flood of love you'd heard about from friends and movies and every card at the baby shower. What came instead was exhaustion, or a strange flatness, or the sense of holding someone else's child. Then, a few hours or days later, a worse thought arrived: what kind of mother doesn't feel this?

A lot of them, it turns out. Not bonding with your baby right away is common, and parents rarely say it out loud, which is a big part of why it feels so shameful. This post covers where the idea of instant love came from, why the feeling so often runs late, and the signs that something more than time is needed.

Where "instant bonding" came from

Part of the story is cultural, and part is a piece of 1970s science that got bigger in the retelling. In their 1976 book Maternal-Infant Bonding, the pediatricians Marshall Klaus and John Kennell argued for a sensitive period right after birth, when skin-to-skin contact helped a mother attach to her baby. Their work did real good. It pushed hospitals to stop taking newborns off to the nursery for hours and to keep parents and babies together.

The strong version of the claim didn't hold up. Later studies found the effect of those first hours was small and hard to replicate, and Klaus and Kennell softened their own position in later editions. The psychologist Diane Eyer went further in her 1992 book Mother-Infant Bonding: A Scientific Fiction, arguing that the idea had mostly become a source of guilt for mothers who "missed the window." Adoptive parents, parents whose babies spent weeks in the NICU, and parents who were too sick or scared at the birth to feel much of anything go on to have close relationships with their children all the time.

Bonding is not always a lightning strike. For many parents, it's a slow sunrise. And that dawn is no less real.

Why the feeling can lag

Bonding is built more than it's felt. It accumulates through thousands of small exchanges: a feed, a diaper, a look held a second longer than the one before. Researchers who study parent-infant "synchrony," the developmental psychologist Ruth Feldman most prominently, look at the back-and-forth of gaze, touch and voice between parent and baby, and how both of them learn that rhythm over the first months. Two weeks in, neither of you has had much practice.

Some other things that commonly get in the way:

  • A frightening birth. If labor ended in an emergency, part of you may still be bracing, and it's hard to soften toward anyone while you're braced.

  • Sleep loss, which flattens almost every feeling, the good ones included.

  • A newborn who doesn't give much back yet. Social smiles usually show up somewhere around six to eight weeks, and before that the relationship can feel like it runs in one direction.

  • A physical recovery that takes up most of your attention.

  • Fear carried over from before. Parents who lost a pregnancy before this one sometimes hold back without meaning to, a protective distance that rarely gets talked about.

  • Postpartum depression or anxiety, which I'll come back to below.

And sometimes you've simply met this person very recently. Love for a particular human usually comes from knowing them, and knowing someone takes a while.

You didn't fail to love your baby. You're getting to know a person you only just met. And that takes the time it takes.

Going through the motions counts

The early weeks are hard on nearly everyone, and I wrote separately about why no one warns you how hard the newborn stage is. In that fog, many parents describe feeling like a competent night nurse rather than a mother. They feed, change and rock the baby, and feel very little while doing it.

That's worth hearing plainly: going through the motions is how bonding happens. Your baby has no idea whether you felt a rush of love while you warmed the bottle. What registers is that someone came, and then came again.

Donald Winnicott, the English pediatrician and psychoanalyst, wrote about the "good enough" mother, meaning a parent who is reliably there, responds well enough most of the time, and repairs the misses. He wasn't describing someone in a state of bliss. A parent who keeps getting up at 3 a.m. in a fog is doing exactly what he meant.

In the Salvadoran culture I grew up in, and in many Latin American families, there's a tradition called la cuarentena: roughly forty days after the birth when the new mother is supposed to rest while relatives cook, clean and take care of most everything else. Not every part of it suits every family, and some of the rules can feel confining. Its basic premise seems right to me, though. A new mother needs looking after so she has something left over for the baby. If nobody is looking after you, I'd fix that first, before drawing any conclusions about how bonded you feel.

Difficulty bonding is often a symptom, not a sentence. When the depression or exhaustion lifts, the love that was buried underneath tends to surface.

When it's more than time

Delayed bonding by itself usually isn't cause for alarm. It's more concerning when it lasts and comes with other things: feeling numb or hopeless most days, guilt that won't let up, dread about being alone with the baby, frightening intrusive thoughts, or a belief that your baby would be better off with someone else. Those can be signs of postpartum depression or anxiety, and both are common and treatable.

If you want to compare what you're feeling with a symptom list, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists has a patient page on postpartum depression. The National Institute of Mental Health has a plain-language guide to perinatal depression as well.

One Dutch study, by Evi de Cock and colleagues (2016), followed several hundred mothers and fathers from pregnancy to their child's second birthday. Parents whose bond stayed low over that time were more likely to be dealing with anxiety and parenting stress, and to have less support from a partner. I find that useful rather than discouraging. A bond that isn't growing is often tangled up with problems that can be treated, which makes it a reason to ask for help rather than wait.

If symptoms like these have lasted more than two weeks, ask your OB, midwife or doctor for a postpartum mood screening. Many pediatric offices also screen parents at well-baby visits, so your baby's next appointment is a reasonable place to bring it up. If you're having thoughts of harming yourself or your baby, call or text 988, the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, or go to the nearest emergency room.

Things that help in the meantime

Do the loving things before you feel them. Skin-to-skin, talking to your baby while you change them, copying their little sounds, a few minutes of looking at their face. None of it requires feeling anything first, and over time the feeling tends to follow.

Lower the stakes on each moment. If you check "do I feel it yet?" every time you pick up the baby, every feed becomes a test. Short stretches of easy attention do more than long sessions of staring and waiting.

Treat sleep and food as part of the treatment. That's easier said than done with a newborn. Still, if a partner or relative can take one night feed, let them.

And say it to one person. "I don't feel connected to my baby yet" is a hard sentence to get out. Once someone has heard it without recoiling, it usually loses a good deal of its power over you.

Where therapy fits

Sometimes the bond is blocked by something time won't move on its own: a birth that still replays at night, a depression that flattens everything, or an early history of being parented that makes closeness feel complicated in ways that are hard to name. I work in a relational, attachment-based way, which suits this problem well. We can go back through a hard birth so your body can stop bracing for it, look at what closeness meant in the family you grew up in, and treat depression or anxiety directly if either is part of the picture.

You don't need to be sure something is "wrong" before you reach out. My perinatal therapy page describes how I work with new and expecting parents. If what you're reading here sounds close to depression, the postpartum depression therapy page is a good next stop. If it's mostly worry and dread, start with postpartum anxiety therapy instead.

Dania Uritskiy, LICSW

Dania is a therapist in Seattle, Washington. Most of her clients are high-functioning adults struggling with stress and anxiety, first- and second-generation immigrants, intercultural couples, and new parents. Se sees people in person by the Edmonds waterfront and virtually across Washington State.

About Vida Counseling · More about Dania · Book a free consult

https://www.counselingvida.com/
Next
Next

Amazon, Microsoft, and Burnout: Mental Health in Seattle Tech